What Can I Do If An Insurance Company Denies My Car Accident Claim?

Car accidents are always frustrating. The sudden onset of various issues related to an accident — damage to your vehicle, financial expenses, and potential injuries — can quickly combine to create a situation that turns your life upside down. On top of the typical aggravation of dealing with the aftermath of a car accident, you may also have to face the unexpected challenge of having your insurance claim denied. It is important to know why this happens, how it happens, how to respond, and how to avoid it in the future.

If you have been in a car accident, no matter where you are currently in the claims process, your most important move is to hire an experienced car accident lawyer to guide you. If you are just starting the process of preparing to file your claim, have had your claim denied, or are looking for other legal options that may be available to you in the aftermath of your accident, putting your case in the hands of a knowledgeable attorney with a track record of providing insight and representation to others like you is crucial. Your opportunity to seek the compensation you need after your accident — even if you learn your claim is denied — is not something to walk away from. Let a skilled legal professional seek a more favorable outcome.

Contact a car accident lawyer today to schedule a consultation to discuss the details of your case and learn more about the steps you can take to address your denial of insurance claim.

Car Accident Insurance Claim Overview

Two drivers arguing after a car accident, one making a phone call to an insurance agent. Traffic accident and insurance concept.

As anyone who has been in a car accident will likely tell you, car accident insurance claims play a critical role in providing individuals with financial relief following traffic accidents. When someone is involved in an accident, their insurance coverage (and potentially the coverage carried by other parties involved) is a pivotal element in addressing different expenses that arise from the accident — such as medical bills, vehicle repairs, property damage, and other losses.

Though carrying car insurance is important (and, in most cases, required by law for licensed drivers), many drivers are caught off-guard when their insurance claims are denied. Some individuals are surprised to even learn it’s possible to have their accident claim denied. Rest assured, it does happen. Though insurance coverage should help alleviate the financial burdens in the wake of an accident, there are still important factors to consider and keep in mind when dealing with your insurer to avoid unnecessary obstacles that might eventually lead to a claim denial.

Understanding Insurance Claim Denials

After you receive a denial, first understand insurance claim denials themselves, including the process by which a denial takes place and common reasons why an insurance claim may be denied.

The Denial Process

Insurance providers must adhere to a strict set of laws and regulations that govern the industry. These rules and procedures include the process of denying claims. If you are wondering if your car accident insurance claim may be denied, you should look for signs that this process is starting. The typical insurance claim denial process includes the following steps:

  • Initial Claim Submission
  • Claim Evaluation by the Insurance Company
  • Notification of Denial

If your insurance claim is denied, your insurance provider will also provide its reasoning and explanation for why this action took place, whether because of lack of sufficient coverage, policy exclusions, disputes over liability in the accident, or insufficient evidence to support the claim. A car accident lawyer can review this notification from your insurance provider.

Common Reasons for Insurance Claim Denials

Your car accident insurance claim may eventually be denied for various reasons. Though having your insurance claim denied can be a frustrating experience, understanding the common reasons for these denials is important for individuals seeking solutions following car accidents. Some of the more common reasons why an insurance provider may deny your car accident claim include:

  • Lack of Coverage
  • Policy Exclusions
  • Disputes Over Liability
  • Insufficient Evidence

Knowing about these potential reasons for denial can provide policyholders with the power to address them proactively. It is always wise for policyholders to periodically review their coverage, familiarize themselves with any exclusions within their policies, and gather comprehensive evidence to support their claims.

Steps to Take After an Insurance Claim Denial

Though receiving notification of a car insurance claim denial is never desirable, it does not have to be the end of your attempt at seeking a favorable resolution. By diligently following specific steps, you can improve your chances of successfully addressing the denial and achieving a favorable outcome. At any stage, having an experienced lawyer working with you is always the best option. Your attorney can explain the process, lead you in the right direction, and avoid spinning your wheels or meeting unnecessary obstacles.

Reviewing the Denial Letter

You will receive written notice when your insurance company denies your car accident claim. The first step to take is to carefully review this denial letter to better understand the insurance company’s stated reasons for the denial. Learning about these specific reasons for denial is critical when it comes time to determine the appropriate response.

You should also work with your lawyer to review the letter in detail to search for any errors or misinterpretations since there is a possibility that inaccuracies in the insurance company’s investigation process led to the denial.

Gathering Evidence

You and your lawyer must gather all relevant supportive evidence in response to your claim denial. You should thoroughly document all aspects of your car accident, including the damage to your vehicle, medical treatment for any accident-related injuries, and any other pertinent information. Working with your attorney to assemble this evidence will give you a strong foundation to challenge the denial of your claim.

Seeking out witness statements and the testimony of experts can also add substantial support to your claim. Collecting statements from people who saw your accident or relevant experts will allow you and your lawyer to build a more compelling argument to challenge the denial.

Communicating with the Insurance Company

You can always maintain cordial and professional communication with your insurance provider throughout the process. That said, you should let your lawyer handle all communications with the insurance company after a car accident, and especially after a claim denial. That way, you prevent yourself from making any statements that the insurance company can potentially use against you.

Why You Need a Car Accident Lawyer

Model car with a judge figure on a table.

The complexities of insurance policies and the laws and regulations that govern them, along with the sometimes lack of cooperation from the insurance company, necessitates hiring professional legal representation to protect your rights and pursue an outcome that suits your best interests.

Recognizing your need for legal representation and understanding the benefits of having a skilled lawyer in your corner can empower you to make well-informed decisions as you seek a remedy to the denial of your car accident insurance claim.

A knowledgeable lawyer with extensive experience in dealing with car accident insurance claim denials gives you an advocate who possesses the insight to interpret the terms of your policy and know how all laws and regulations apply to your situation. Additionally, having a lawyer on your side can give you the following benefits:

  • Experience in Insurance Disputes
  • Negotiation Skill When Dealing with Claims Adjusters
  • Initiating a Lawsuit (if necessary)
  • Dedicated Protection of Your Rights and Interests

While often helpful and professional, insurance companies may sometimes be less than cooperative, particularly in contentious situations such as claim denials. Give yourself the best opportunity to reach the result you want by hiring an experienced car accident lawyer.

Proactive Measures to Avoid Insurance Claim Denials

Though a back-and-forth process with your insurance company can be frustrating and challenging, having a lawyer take a more proactive approach can help decrease the likelihood of facing such contentious situations to begin with. When your attorney proactively engages your insurance company and clearly communicates your situation, you put yourself in a better position to avoid a claim denial in the event of an accident.

Some additional common strategies may give you an advantage if you are in an accident and let you move forward sooner.

Understanding Your Insurance Policies

Reviewing your car insurance policy thoroughly with your lawyer is a wise practice. Pay close attention to coverage limits and exclusions present in your policy. Understanding the scope of your coverage can ensure any accident claims are aligned with the provisions of your policy.

Seek clarification from your insurance provider if anything is unclear. Maintaining open communication between your lawyer and the insurance company can help avoid misunderstandings in an accident or a claim dispute.

Importance of Prompt Accident Reporting

Following a car accident, reporting it quickly and accurately to your insurance company is imperative. Timely reporting allows the claims process to begin swiftly and prevents complications that may arise from a delay in notifying your provider.

Document all accident scene details to preserve evidence and strengthen your initial claim. This evidence at the scene can include photographs, contact information for any involved parties, and witness statements.

Trust Your Medical Professionals

Immediately seeking medical attention and evaluation following your accident is critical for health reasons and your insurance claim. Obtaining medical records and documentation for your diagnosis and treatment is key to supporting your claim and showing your insurance provider your need for a favorable resolution following your accident.

Contact an Experienced Car Accident Lawyer for Help

Few things can make the aftermath of a car accident more stressful than finding out your insurance claim has been denied. Such a development can easily leave you feeling lost and uncertain about where to turn for help, what to do, or your options moving forward. With the damage you have already endured in your accident still lingering, you can’t afford to give up and accept an insurance claim denial that may be in error. Fortunately, by working with a knowledgeable car accident lawyer, you can get the assistance and legal counsel you need to review your insurance claim denial, explore any potential alternative options, and get your situation moving in the right direction.

If you are trying to pick up the pieces in the wake of a car accident — whether you are looking to avoid having your insurance claim denied or have already been notified of a denial — you have the right to seek help to address your situation to bring about a more favorable resolution. By consulting with a car accident attorney, you can obtain the guidance of a legal professional who is not only well-versed in the laws and regulations pertaining to car accident and auto insurance but also has experience with leading other people through the process of dealing with insurance claim denials.

If you are looking for help, take the most important step today by contacting a skilled car accident lawyer and scheduling a consultation to discuss your accident, your insurance claim denial, and the best course of action moving forward.

Consultations with Car Accident Lawyers are Always Free

Personal Injury Lawyer
Car Accident Attorney, Matthew H. Bligh

Know that consultations with personal injury lawyers are always free. This means you can schedule a meeting with an attorney to discuss your case and get valuable advice without worrying about any upfront costs.

During these consultations, the lawyer will listen to your story, ask questions to gather all the necessary information and evaluate the strength of your case. They will honestly assess your situation and guide you on the best course of action. Whether it’s negotiating with insurance companies, filing a lawsuit, or pursuing alternative dispute resolution methods, the lawyer will explain your legal options.

Access to free consultations is beneficial for brain injury victims, as it allows them to make informed decisions about their legal rights and potential compensation. It also gives them the opportunity to find a lawyer who understands the complexities of brain injury cases and has experience in handling similar claims.

Remember, seeking legal help after a brain injury can significantly improve your chances of receiving the compensation you deserve. Consultations with car accident lawyers are an invaluable resource that can provide you with the guidance and support you need during this challenging time. So don’t hesitate to take advantage of this opportunity and schedule your free consultation today.

Filed Under: Car Accidents

For a free legal consultation, call 516-451-7900

Practice Areas

Our Long Island Injury Lawyers Have Experience In

Truck Accidents
Accidents on the highways can be lethal events
Bicycle Accidents
Riding a bicycle should not be unsafe
Car Accidents
If you have been seriously injured, call our firm
Motorcycle Accidents
Motorcycle accidents often result in serious injury
Medical Malpractice
Medical mistakes can cause death ruin lives
Wrongful Death
When negligence results in the death of a loved me
Premises Liability
When hurt in a location, someone has to take responsibility
Brain Injury
Brain injuries can have long term severe effects
Dog Bites
Dog bites can cause serious injury


Client Testimonials

“The amount I could get for my case was limited (due…

– Craig S., Car Accident Client

“I want to thank Rosenberg & Gluck and Staff For the…

– Steve G., Personal Injury Client

Erin was able to get me over double what was originally…

– Nicole E., Car Accident Client

See More Testimonials


Get Your Free Case Review

"*" indicates required fields

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.