What If I Am Partly To Blame For My Car Accident?

Car accidents are an all-too-common occurrence in our modern world, with a wide range of causes and a variety of scenarios of fault and liability. While many car accident cases can be cut and dry, with one party being clearly to blame for the crash, other cases may be far more complicated. How does compensation work in car accidents where multiple parties may share the fault for the crash? What are your legal options if you are in such an accident?

Though legal issues and the aftermath of a car accident can often be confusing, having the help of a knowledgeable car accident lawyer can take some of the stress and burden off your shoulders. If you have been in a car accident and are concerned that you are partially to blame for the crash, you still have rights to protect and interests that you must consider carefully. Contact an experienced car accident attorney today to schedule a consultation to learn more about your options and how to proceed.

Overview of Car Accident Fault

In the aftermath of a car accident, determining fault is the element on which everything else rests. If you are partially at fault for your accident, you may wonder how this will affect your opportunity to seek compensation for your injuries and other damages. In many cases in different jurisdictions around the country, fault can be divided among multiple parties, so being familiar with how the process works is important.

Understanding Shared Fault in Crashes

Anxious drivers standing beside damaged vehicles following a car accident.

It is worthwhile to give a brief overview of how shared fault works following car accidents. Each state has different laws, but most allow victims to recover some compensation even if they share some blame.

Under a shared fault system, the fault for a car accident is spread across multiple parties, assigning different percentages of fault to the different parties involved in the accident based on their level of responsibility for the accident. The maximum allowable amount of compensation is then subtracted from the receiving party’s percentage of fault.

Impact on Personal Injury Cases

As an example, say a car accident occurred in which one of the parties suffered a personal injury. In this example, the injured party was found to be 25 percent at fault for the accident due to speeding when the collision happened. If the court awards compensation to the injured party, they will only be entitled to 75 percent of that total amount due to their 25 percent share of fault in the accident.

Even if compensation is less than a victim’s losses due to partial blame, it can still be substantial and is always worth pursuing.

The Role of a Lawyer in Handling Partial Fault Cases

Now that you have a basic understanding of how shared fault works in car accident cases in which multiple parties share fault, your real focus should be on learning how working with an experienced car accident lawyer can benefit your case as you seek to maximize your compensation despite your partial liability in the accident. Moving quickly to secure the services of a skilled legal representative can pay off in multiple ways, depending on the details of your situation.

Early Consultation & Case Evaluation

There are instances in which the viability of your case can be greatly affected by how quickly you act to retain legal counsel and start the process of evaluating your case. Delaying your consultation with an attorney can result in critical evidence being lost, causing you to have more of an uphill battle to obtain the compensation you need to cover your expenses. Seeking legal guidance as soon as possible will allow you to have your situation evaluated quickly and ensure relevant information is gathered promptly and preserved for your case.

Assessing the Strength of Your Case

Lawyers play a crucial role in objectively assessing the overall strength of cases. By examining available evidence, witness statements, law enforcement documentation, and other relevant factors, attorneys can advise clients and provide realistic evaluations of their cases. This allows individuals to better understand the challenges they may face in their cases and the likelihood of reaching a successful outcome. Having a lawyer who gives you insight into the prospects of your case and sets realistic expectations can help you make more well-informed decisions.

Maximizing Compensation

As mentioned above, lawyers occupy a pivotal position in securing financial compensation for individuals who share fault in a car accident. By evaluating evidence, building your case, engaging in negotiations, and leveraging expert witness testimony where available, a knowledgeable car accident attorney can ensure your case goes through a fair process, and you have the best opportunity to obtain the level of compensation you need after your accident.

Negotiating with Insurance Companies

Lawyers possess extensive knowledge and insight into the negotiation process. Your attorney will have a full understanding of the complexities of insurance claims and how they pertain to your car accident, allowing them to advocate for fair and rightful compensation on your behalf. Through the presentation of a compelling argument and leveraging legal knowledge, your lawyer’s aim is to secure the best available settlement in your case, even in situations where the fault is shared.

Presenting Evidence to Support Your Claim

As part of the legal process, attorneys are well-versed in gathering evidence and documentation to support their clients’ claims. This process can include many strategies, including reconstructing the accident, obtaining witness statements, assembling relevant documentation, and more. By building a persuasive case, your attorney will seek to emphasize the percentage of fault carried by the other involved parties to position you in a more favorable light.

Utilizing Expert Witness Testimony

For cases requiring specialized knowledge, lawyers will often employ expert witnesses. These expert witnesses can provide crucial insight into the details of your car accident. Some common instances in which expert witnesses may give beneficial testimony include accidents in which vehicle dynamics or specific medical treatments are involved. This information can carry significant weight with the court, strengthening your case and adding greater credibility to your argument for fair compensation.

Building a Strong Case

You must have a strong case to challenge wrongful blame and prove the blame of other drivers. Your attorney will provide critical legal and logistical support for your claim. Lawyers build a robust legal strategy to aggressively advocate for you when you are seeking to establish greater liability on the part of the other individuals involved in your accident. Through the systematic gathering of evidence and documentation, establishing a timeline of events, and establishing the specifics of the damages you have incurred due to the accident, your lawyer can present an argument that maximizes the responsibility of the other party. This, in turn, can maximize your compensation.

Gathering Evidence to Prove the Fault of Other Parties

A client listens to a lawyer discussing an embezzlement case, preparing evidence for a lawsuit.

Attorneys know how to collect evidence supporting their clients’ claims while highlighting the fault of opposing parties. Various types of evidence collected include accident reports obtained from law enforcement, eyewitness testimony, photographs or video footage from the accident scene, and other assets supporting your case. Gathering comprehensive evidence helps lay the foundation of a clear narrative to support your version of the events surrounding your accident.

Establishing a Clear Timeline

Constructing a clear chronological timeline of the accident is vital for demonstrating the sequence of events leading up to and immediately following car crashes. Your attorney will work to firmly establish this timeline to reinforce your perspective and highlight the crucial role the other involved party played in causing the accident. Your lawyer will work closely with you to ensure the comprehensiveness and accuracy of the timeline presented to the court.

Documenting Damages & Injuries

Cases filed following car accidents that resulted in significant property damage and/or physical injuries benefit from a preponderance of documentation to illustrate the damage. Your lawyer will gather medical records, vehicle repair estimates, and other relevant documentation to support the harm you suffered from the accident. The more documentation your attorney can collect and present to support your case, the more successful you can be in demonstrating the culpability of the other party.

Protecting Yourself Against Wrongful Blame

In cases where an individual is partly to blame for a car accident, that individual’s lawyer will employ certain strategies to protect their client from potential attempts made by opposing counsel to wrongfully shift greater blame to one side. By counteracting these attempts, establishing primary responsibility on the part of the other party, and refuting the opposing side’s arguments, your attorney will seek to shield you from receiving any additional blame and seek an outcome that puts you in the most favorable position available.

Strategies to Counteract Blame-Shifting

Your lawyer can anticipate and effectively counter any attempts made by the other side to shift undue blame onto you. This involves an approach to identify and preemptively address assertions that might serve to deflect responsibility from the opposing party. By doing so, your attorney can maintain the integrity of your case and put you in a position to showcase the greater fault of the other party.

Demonstrating the Primary Responsibility of Other Parties

Establishing the primary responsibility held by the other parties involved in your car accident case can include presenting evidence that clearly indicates the extent of the opposing party’s negligence or recklessness. By shifting the focus onto the primary responsibility of the other party, your attorney will look to redirect the blame for the accident away from you, providing you with a stronger opportunity to make a claim for greater compensation.

Refuting Opposing Arguments

Thorough analysis, extensive research, and presenting compelling counterarguments to undermine any attempts made by the other side to wrongfully shift blame onto you for your car accident are all common tactics employed by skilled lawyers. Anticipating and addressing such potential claims allows your attorney to safeguard your interests and avoid leaving you exposed to aggressive strategies to discredit your claims or paint you in a negative light.

We cannot overstate the benefits of having an experienced car accident attorney on your side. From the most basic legal guidance to ensuring fair treatment and protection of your rights, having a knowledgeable attorney in your corner throughout the process can give you peace of mind through challenging times and confidence that your case and prospects for success are in good hands.

Legal representation is especially important if you face blame for your crash. Insurance companies will take advantage of you and try to convince you there is no compensation available because you shared fault. A lawyer in your state will determine your true rights under your state’s laws.

Contact an Experienced Car Accident Lawyer for Help

Personal Injury Lawyer
Car Accident Lawyer, Matthew H. Bligh

Like any legal matter, trusting a skilled attorney to handle your case is your best option. In the aftermath of a car accident, you already have enough to deal with. Damage to your vehicle, potential injuries leading to medical expenses, and other issues can leave you feeling overwhelmed. Without the proper legal guidance to point you in the right direction and keep you on track, you can easily find yourself drowning in the complicated landscape of car accident liability, insurance, and legal troubles. There is a better way to handle this type of situation, and it’s available to you.

If you are partially to blame for your car accident, it doesn’t mean you have to give up on the possibility of obtaining financial compensation to pay for the expenses you’ve incurred due to the accident. By working with an experienced personal injury attorney, you can take the appropriate steps to fight for your fair share of compensation. A knowledgeable car accident attorney can assess your situation, evaluate your legal options, and plot out a course of action to put you in the best position to pursue a favorable outcome. Best of all, your attorney can do all this for you while you focus on the most important thing: recovering from your injuries. Reach out to a car accident lawyer today to schedule a consultation to discuss your case.

Filed Under: Car Accidents

For a free legal consultation, call 516-451-7900

Practice Areas

Our Long Island Injury Lawyers Have Experience In

Truck Accidents
Accidents on the highways can be lethal events
Bicycle Accidents
Riding a bicycle should not be unsafe
Car Accidents
If you have been seriously injured, call our firm
Motorcycle Accidents
Motorcycle accidents often result in serious injury
Medical Malpractice
Medical mistakes can cause death ruin lives
Wrongful Death
When negligence results in the death of a loved me
Premises Liability
When hurt in a location, someone has to take responsibility
Brain Injury
Brain injuries can have long term severe effects
Dog Bites
Dog bites can cause serious injury


Client Testimonials

“The amount I could get for my case was limited (due…

– Craig S., Car Accident Client

“I want to thank Rosenberg & Gluck and Staff For the…

– Steve G., Personal Injury Client

Erin was able to get me over double what was originally…

– Nicole E., Car Accident Client

See More Testimonials


Get Your Free Case Review

"*" indicates required fields

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.