Does New York Have a One-Bite Rule?

When a dog bite occurs, the victim often faces immediate physical pain, long-term emotional distress, the heavy burden of unexpected medical bills, and a confusing legal claim.

The laws governing dog bites vary across states, and in New York, they present a unique mixture of statutory and case law. Here’s a brief overview of the dog bite laws in New York and how a dog bite lawyer can assist you in such complex situations.

What Is the One-Bite Rule?

Some jurisdictions follow the one-bite rule. It holds a dog owner liable for bites only if the owner knew or had a reason to believe that the dog tended to bite or act aggressively. The rule gives dog owners one free bite before victims can hold them liable for an attack.

With the complexity and variability of dog bite laws, a lawyer can guide you through interpreting these laws in the context of your case, detail your rights and obligations, and assist you in pursuing a claim if necessary.

How New York Handles the One-Bite Rule

Every state has its unique blend of legal rules for dog bites. New York laws are not as straightforward as they seem. Instead of adhering to the typical one-bite rule, New York employs a complex combination of statutory and case law, distinguishing it from other states.

Does New York Have a One-Bite Rule?

New York’s approach to dog bites diverges from the traditional one-bite rule. An owner is liable for their animal’s injurious actions only if the dog or animal, to the owner’s knowledge, has shown a prior vicious propensity.

For a victim to establish liability on the owner’s part, they must prove that the owner knew their animal’s previous behavior could lead to an attack. While some victims see this as a free pass for certain owners to have dangerous dogs out among the public, you can still hold these pet owners liable if their dog bites you.

Understanding Dog Bite Laws

After a dog bite, understanding your legal rights can allow you to navigate recovery with more confidence and peace of mind. General principles apply in most regions, yet the nuances and intricacies of dog bite laws vary significantly from jurisdiction to jurisdiction.

Dog bite laws generally protect victims of dog attacks and hold pet owners accountable for their pet’s actions. These laws often cover pet owners’ legal obligations, circumstances under which an owner may be liable for an attack, and potential defenses available to the owner.

When Can You Hold Owners Liable for a Dog Bite?

The New York statute that applies to dog bites is Agriculture and Markets Law § 123. Under this statute, if a plaintiff can prove that the owner knew that the dog had a prior vicious propensity, the owner is strictly liable for any damages that the dog bite caused.

Reasons that a court may hold a dog owner liable include:

  • If the dog often jumps aggressively on people.
  • If the dog has received training to fight.
  • If the dog displayed previously vicious behavior.
  • If there have been prior complaints against the dog.
  • If the dog has previously bitten or attacked someone.

The victim doesn’t necessarily need to prove that the dog had bitten someone before. They need to confirm that the owner knew that the dog was dangerous in some way. If the plaintiff can perform both actions, the owner may be liable. A lawyer is invaluable at this stage. A dangerous dog may often fit into more than one of these categories.

When to Call a Dog Bite Lawyer

If you or a loved one has been a dog bite victim, seek legal help immediately. Once you’ve received medical attention, you should contact a dog bite lawyer and explain your situation.

An experienced personal injury lawyer can guide you through what may be an uncertain and confusing process. They can assess your claim and advise you on your legal options and the best action. During this initial consultation, a lawyer may walk you through collecting and curating evidence, describing how they can use it to establish liability and fight for the compensation you deserve.

How Much Is My Dog Bite Case Worth?

The value of a dog bite case can vary significantly based on many factors. These include the severity of the injuries, their long-term impact on the victim’s life, and the financial costs of recovery. A lawyer can assess the nature of the case, review the facts, and provide an estimate of your claim’s value. Your lawyer can also guide you through negotiations with the insurance company to obtain the best possible outcome for your case.

Having a Lawyer on Your Side

Your lawyer can interpret the unique and intricate characteristics of New York’s dog bite laws, assess your situation under those laws, and guide you through the legal process. They will protect your rights and obtain the best possible outcome for your case.

From collecting the necessary evidence to dealing with insurance companies and possibly filing a lawsuit, a lawyer’s guidance can make an overwhelming process much more manageable.

A Lawyer Can Collect Evidence and Build a Case

After a dog bite, you must gather and preserve evidence. Your lawyer can collect information, such as eyewitness testimonies, photographs of the injuries, and the dog owner’s details. They can also aid in building a solid case by piecing together this evidence compellingly.

The Role of a Lawyer in Dealing With Insurance Companies and Negotiating Settlements

Insurance companies often attempt to minimize their payout or even avoid it. Your lawyer can provide indispensable aid in handling insurance companies, ensuring you receive a fair settlement for your injuries.

If negotiations with the insurance company aren’t successful, your lawyer will guide you through filing a lawsuit. Even if it doesn’t come to that, having your lawyer negotiate a settlement on your behalf is incredibly beneficial. Their legal knowledge ensures they represent you wholeheartedly and protect your interests.

Compensation After a Dog Bite

Navigating the legal landscape following a dog bite may be confusing and stressful. A personal injury lawyer can guide you through the process and work to secure compensation for your medical expenses, pain, and suffering. This compensation can significantly alleviate the financial stress of recovery from a dog bite.

Navigating the aftermath of a dog bite is usually a complicated process. Understanding New York’s unique dog bite laws and making sense of the legal and medical implications can be overwhelming. A dedicated personal injury lawyer’s skills prove invaluable in this situation.

Understanding Your Rights as a Dog Bite Victim

As a dog bite victim, you can pursue compensation for your injuries. This usually covers medical bills, pain and emotional suffering, loss of income, and other expenses related to the attack. Engaging a lawyer to protect these rights and guide you through the claims process is crucial.

The Timeframe for Filing a Dog Bite Lawsuit

Timing is critical when seeking legal recourse. Most states have a statute of limitations for personal injury cases, including dog bites. In New York, for instance, you must typically file a dog bite lawsuit within three years from the date of the bite.

Failing to act within this timeframe could bar the victim from recovering any compensation for their injuries, regardless of the merits of their case. Exceptions to the statute of limitations include the injured person being a minor or the person who allegedly caused the injury leaving the state of New York at some point after the dog bite occurred. Your lawyer will meet all legal deadlines to keep your case viable and advise you on how to proceed if any exceptions apply to you.

Moving Forward After a Dog Bite

Experiencing a dog bite may be traumatic, often leaving the victim to cope with emotional, physical, and financial fallout. Recovery can be daunting when the victim deals with medical bills and legal complexities. A dog bite may lead to substantial emotional and physical distress and financial burdens. Acknowledging these challenges is the first crucial step toward recovery.

You must evaluate your mental well-being after seeing a doctor or other healthcare professional. If you missed work or faced significant emotional distress, tally up your expenses. You’ll need this information when you contact a lawyer and attempt to establish liability.

If this step overwhelms you, seek a lawyer first. A dog bite lawyer can work with you on this step so you can focus purely on your recovery and move forward after the devastating dog bite.

The Psychological Impact of Dog Bites

Besides physical harm, dog bites may lead to substantial emotional distress. Victims may experience post-traumatic stress disorder, anxiety, and a lifelong fear of dogs. You should not underestimate the psychological toll because professional mental health support, such as counseling or therapy, in aiding your recovery.

How Many People Suffer Dog Bites Each Year?

Animal bites, including dog bites, are a significant cause of injury to people worldwide, including in New York. According to the World Health Organization (WHO), dogs bite approximately 4.5 million people every year in the United States. Of those, nearly 885,000 seek medical care, 30,000 have reconstructive procedures, 3 to 18 percent develop infections, and 10 to 20 result in fatalities.

The WHO estimates that dogs account for 76 to 94 percent of animal bite injuries, with children generally the most at risk. They are also at the highest risk for fatal head and neck injuries. No matter whom the dog bites, it can be a traumatic event causing physical injuries and significant psychological damage. These numbers are frightening, especially if you or a loved one has been a dog bite victim.

Matthew H. Bligh, Dog Bite Attorney in New York
New York Dog Bite Lawyer, Matthew H. Bligh

From collecting evidence and negotiating with insurance companies to potentially filing a lawsuit, a dog bite lawyer can guide you throughout this challenging journey.

You do not have to face this situation alone. Seeking professional legal help eases the process considerably, assists in understanding your rights, and works toward obtaining the compensation you rightfully deserve. In the days following a dog bite, focus on your recovery and allow a dedicated personal injury lawyer in New York to guide you through the legal complexities.

Filed Under: Dog Bite

For a free legal consultation, call 516-451-7900

Practice Areas

Our Long Island Injury Lawyers Have Experience In

Truck Accidents
Accidents on the highways can be lethal events
Bicycle Accidents
Riding a bicycle should not be unsafe
Car Accidents
If you have been seriously injured, call our firm
Motorcycle Accidents
Motorcycle accidents often result in serious injury
Medical Malpractice
Medical mistakes can cause death ruin lives
Wrongful Death
When negligence results in the death of a loved me
Premises Liability
When hurt in a location, someone has to take responsibility
Brain Injury
Brain injuries can have long term severe effects
Dog Bites
Dog bites can cause serious injury


Client Testimonials

“The amount I could get for my case was limited (due…

– Craig S., Car Accident Client

“I want to thank Rosenberg & Gluck and Staff For the…

– Steve G., Personal Injury Client

Erin was able to get me over double what was originally…

– Nicole E., Car Accident Client

See More Testimonials


Get Your Free Case Review

"*" indicates required fields

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.