When Is the Trucking Company Liable?

Many trucking accidents lead to severe injuries, and some of them end in fatalities. Holding the at-fault party responsible helps the victim and their loved ones recover and get their life back on track.

If you suffered injuries in a truck accident, you may wonder who is responsible. The liable parties in such crashes can vary. You must identify all of them to recover maximum damages.  

Working with an experienced truck accident attorney in Long Island allows you to establish who the responsible parties are and make informed decisions about your claim. Determining whether the trucking company is liable allows your attorney to build a strong case.

Understanding Liability in Trucking Accidents

Thousands of truck-related crashes occur every year. The number of these accidents is growing steadily, especially when it comes to large trucks. Since trucks weigh 20 to 30 times more than passenger cars, the consequences of these crashes are often severe.

Liability refers to the legal responsibility of a party for the damages or injuries resulting from an accident. In the case of trucking accidents, determining liability can be complex due to the involvement of multiple parties and various factors. Understanding the elements that determine liability is crucial in seeking compensation for the incurred damages.


Negligence plays a vital role in determining liability in trucking accidents. It refers to the failure of a party to exercise reasonable care resulting in harm to others.

Negligence can occur on the part of the truck driver, trucking company, maintenance personnel, or other involved parties. Evidence of negligence, such as traffic violations, driver fatigue, inadequate vehicle maintenance, or failure to follow safety regulations, helps establish liability.

Driver Error

The actions of the truck driver can significantly influence liability in trucking accidents. Driver errors can include speeding, distracted driving, driving under the influence, changing lanes improperly, or failing to yield. Gathering evidence, such as witness statements, police reports, or video footage, can help establish driver error and attribute liability accordingly.

Vicarious Liability

You can hold trucking companies liable for the actions of their employees. If the truck driver was acting within the scope of their employment at the time of the accident, the trucking company may be responsible for any resulting damages. This includes situations where the driver was on-duty, driving a company-owned truck, or carrying out work-related tasks.

Vehicle Maintenance

Trucking companies are responsible for keeping their vehicles in safe and working condition. Failure to perform regular inspections, address mechanical issues promptly, or comply with maintenance regulations can contribute to accidents.

Drivers may also be responsible for inspecting vehicles before getting on the road. An attorney can navigate company policies and rules to determine who is responsible for the maintenance and inspection process.

Third-Party Liability

Liability may extend beyond the truck driver and the trucking company. Other parties, such as manufacturers of defective truck parts, maintenance contractors, or loading companies, might share responsibility for the accident. Identifying third-party involvement and gathering evidence of negligence is crucial in determining liability.

Determining liability in trucking accidents requires a thorough investigation, evidence collection, and analysis of the accident’s circumstances. An attorney can work with you to navigate the legal complexities and identify the responsible parties. By understanding the factors contributing to liability, victims of trucking accidents can seek appropriate compensation for their injuries.

How Trucking Companies Cause Accidents

When Is the Trucking Company Liable

Trucking accidents often stem from the actions and practices of trucking companies. These companies may cut corners regarding safety measures, inspections, and driver expectations to meet strict deadlines and maximize profits.

Ignoring Safety Measures

In an industry where time is of the essence, trucking companies may prioritize meeting delivery deadlines over ensuring the safety of their drivers and other traffic participants. This can cause them to leverage shortcuts in vehicle maintenance, driver training, and adherence to safety regulations. When they compromise safety measures, the risk of accidents increases significantly.

Failing to Arrange Inspections

Trucking companies are responsible for arranging regular inspections and maintenance for their fleet of vehicles. Companies, however, may neglect this crucial aspect for financial reasons or lack proper oversight. Failing to arrange inspections can result in mechanical problems, such as brake malfunctions or tire blowouts. This can lead to accidents on the road.

Setting Unrealistic Schedule Expectations

Trucking companies may put unrealistic expectations on their drivers regarding delivery schedules. This can pressure drivers to meet tight deadlines. They might try to finish the delivery at the expense of taking necessary breaks or adhering to hours-of-service regulations. Fatigued drivers are more prone to errors. They have slower reaction times and impaired judgment, which increases the risk of a truck accident. 

If an accident happened because the driver ignored breaks and hours-of-service regulations, you can hold them and the trucking company liable for the crash. Your attorney can establish fault for the fatigue that caused the accident.

Failing to Provide Adequate Driver Training

Trucking companies are responsible for ensuring the adequate training and qualifications of their drivers. Some employers, however, fail to provide sufficient education or cut corners.

Insufficient training can result in drivers lacking the necessary skills to handle challenging road conditions. Untrained drivers can’t accurately maneuver their vehicles or respond to emergencies. As a result, serious accidents may occur.

Engaging in Negligent Hiring Practices

Trucking companies must conduct thorough background checks and screening processes when hiring drivers. Companies, however, may neglect these essential steps in their rush to fill positions quickly. Hiring drivers without appropriately verifying their qualifications and driving records or conducting drug and alcohol screenings can lead to employing unsafe drivers who are more likely to cause truck accidents.

Not all trucking companies engage in these risky practices; many prioritize safety and compliance. Companies that contribute to accidents through their actions or negligence should be held accountable, however.

How to Prove the Trucking Company’s Liability for the Accident

After your attorney conducts an investigation and determines that the trucking company is liable, they must gather the necessary evidence and build a solid case to support the claim. Proving the trucking company’s liability requires a thorough understanding of negligence laws.

Hire a Qualified Attorney

Seeking the assistance of a qualified attorney with experience in trucking accidents is essential. They possess the knowledge and skills to navigate the complexities of these cases, understand the relevant laws, and gather the necessary evidence to prove liability.

An attorney guides you through the legal process, protects your rights, and advocates for your best interests. Without an attorney, you risk losing your chance to obtain fair compensation.

Victims of truck accidents often suffer from severe injuries, including traumatic brain injuries, serious fractures, and internal organ damage. Focusing on your health is key to regaining quality of life. Juggling legal action and recovery means achieving less than satisfactory results in both tasks. That’s why you should consider your health while your attorney handles the claim.

Establish Negligence

To prove the trucking company’s liability, the victim has to establish negligence. Negligence refers to the failure to exercise reasonable care, resulting in harm to others. In the case of trucking accidents, negligence can include actions such as inadequate vehicle maintenance, negligent hiring practices, insufficient driver training, or violation of safety regulations. Your attorney can investigate and uncover evidence of negligence to support your claim.

Gather Relevant Evidence

Your truck accident lawyer can take prompt action to preserve evidence after a truck accident.

An attorney can collect and preserve facts and material crucial to your case, including:

  • Accident scene evidence: Photographs or videos of the accident scene, skid marks, vehicle damage, and road conditions can provide valuable information about the cause of the accident. If you hire an attorney soon after the crash, they can return to the accident scene and collect this information. 
  • Driver logs and records: Driver logs, employment records, and other relevant documents can help establish if the truck driver suffered fatigue, exceeded their allowed driving hours, or violated safety regulations.
  • Vehicle maintenance records: Gathering maintenance records, inspection reports, and repair invoices can help determine if the trucking company neglected its duty to maintain its vehicles properly.
  • Hiring and training records: Examining the trucking company’s hiring and training records can reveal deficiencies or negligence in their processes, such as hiring unqualified drivers or failing to provide adequate training.
  • Safety regulations: Demonstrating that the trucking company violated applicable safety regulations, such as hours-of-service or vehicle weight restrictions, can strengthen your case.

Your attorney can also look for witnesses to the accident or parties with knowledge of the trucking company’s practices. These people can provide testimony that helps establish liability and strengthen your case. 

Expert Opinions

Qualified opinions may be necessary to establish the trucking company’s liability. Attorneys often hire expert witnesses in such cases. Professionals with specialized knowledge in areas including accident reconstruction, trucking industry standards, or driver safety can provide expert opinions on the trucking company’s negligence.

Negotiating With the Truck Company’s Insurance Provider

When seeking a settlement from the insurance provider of a trucking company, understanding the intricacies of the negotiation process is vital to getting a fair settlement.

Personal injury attorneys possess the knowledge and skills to navigate the complexities of these negotiations. Delegating all interactions with the insurance company to a lawyer allows you to avoid serious errors and emotional stress relating to the negotiation process.

Importance of an Experienced Lawyer

Hire a truck accident lawyer when negotiating with the truck company’s insurance provider. They understand the laws and regulations surrounding these cases and the tactics insurance companies commonly employ. An attorney handles the negotiations for you and fights to receive fair compensation for your injuries and damages.

Higher Insurance Limits

Trucking companies generally have higher insurance limits than independent drivers because operating heavy commercial vehicles involves increased risks. Higher insurance limits mean more funds may cover your damages and injuries.

An experienced lawyer can analyze the truck company’s insurance policy to determine the maximum compensation and use this information to structure the negotiation process. 

Building a Strong Case

Building a solid case with supporting evidence is vital to negotiate effectively with the truck company’s insurance provider.

Your lawyer can gather all relevant documents, such as police reports, medical records, witness statements, and expert opinions, to demonstrate the trucking company’s liability and the extent of your damages. The stronger your case, the more leverage you have during negotiations.

Assessing Damages

An experienced lawyer can assess the full extent of your damages, including medical expenses, lost earnings, pain and suffering, and future medical needs. By accurately quantifying these damages, your attorney gains a powerful tool for negotiating a settlement that adequately compensates relevant losses.

Negotiating a Fair Settlement

Negotiating with the truck company’s insurance provider can involve a complex process. Insurance companies often minimize payouts by offering low settlements or disputing liability.

An experienced lawyer can skillfully negotiate on your behalf, using their knowledge of the trucking industry, insurance laws, and precedents to advocate for your best interests. They can fight for a fair settlement that reflects the true value of your case.

Matthew H. Bligh, Lawyer for Truck Accident in Long Island
Matthew H. Bligh, Long Island Truck Accident Attorney

Holding the Trucking Company Liable

Severe damages and liability issues can make truck accident claims challenging to navigate without legal assistance. If you suffered injuries in a crash resulting from the trucking company’s negligence, you need to fight for compensation. Once the attorney pinpoints liability in a trucking accident, they can leverage their skills and knowledge to achieve a fair settlement.

Filed Under: Truck Accidents

For a free legal consultation, call 516-451-7900

Practice Areas

Our Long Island Injury Lawyers Have Experience In

Truck Accidents
Accidents on the highways can be lethal events
Bicycle Accidents
Riding a bicycle should not be unsafe
Car Accidents
If you have been seriously injured, call our firm
Motorcycle Accidents
Motorcycle accidents often result in serious injury
Medical Malpractice
Medical mistakes can cause death ruin lives
Wrongful Death
When negligence results in the death of a loved me
Premises Liability
When hurt in a location, someone has to take responsibility
Brain Injury
Brain injuries can have long term severe effects
Dog Bites
Dog bites can cause serious injury


Client Testimonials

“The amount I could get for my case was limited (due…

– Craig S., Car Accident Client

“I want to thank Rosenberg & Gluck and Staff For the…

– Steve G., Personal Injury Client

Erin was able to get me over double what was originally…

– Nicole E., Car Accident Client

See More Testimonials


Get Your Free Case Review

"*" indicates required fields

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.